Top 10 Best Water Softeners for Well Water 2020

Hard water is bad for everything, and it is more dangerous when it is coming from underground. It badly affects your hairs and skin and causes scale build-up in pipelines. Also, it damages the home appliances, shower systems, and faucets. Therefore, it is necessary to install a water softener for well water to get rid of the minerals that cause hardness.

Having a best water softener is essential to use for the removal of hard minerals and other constituents, from the well water. Water softeners for well water are a quite efficient and cost-effective solution for water hardness. But selecting the best water softener is not easy since the market is full of great products.

Therefore, to make the selection process easier for you, we have added various factors that you should consider before going to purchase your product. Also, we have reviewed the 10 best water softeners for well water that you will surely find attractive.

Best Well Water Softeners (Comparison)

 Best Water Softeners for Well Water 
Editor’s ChoicePentair WS48-56sxt 10 Fleck Water Softener
  • 14 GPM flow rate

  • 48,000 grain capacity

  • Meter-based regeneration

On the Go OTG4-DBLSOFT Portable Grain RV Water Softener
  • 16,000 grain capacity

  • 1600 gallons/filter

  • Easy installation

Iron Pro 2 Water Softener Fleck 5600SXT
  • 64,000 grain capacity

  • Meter-based regeneration

  • 6-8 PPM filtration

Tier 1 Digital Water Softener for Hard Water
  • 48,000 grain capacity

  • Prevents scale deposits

  • Adjustable cycle times

ABCwaters Fleck 5600sxt Water Softener
  • 12 GPM flow rate

  • 48,000 grain capacity

  • Thin film composite membrane

iSpring WGB32BM 3-Stage Whole House Water Filter
  • 15 GPM flow rate

  • 100,000 gallons of water/filter

  • NSF/FDA-Approved

Fleck 48K 5600sxt Iron Pro Eradicator
  • 48,000 grains capacity

  • LCD display

  • Touchpad control

Water Pro 20 with Fleck 5600sxt Water Softener
  • 12 GPM flow rate

  • 48,000 grains capacity

  • Catalytic & Synthetic carbon shells

Aquasana 500,000 Gallon Well Water Whole House Filter
  • 7 GPM flow rate

  • 50,000 gallons/filter

  • Strong UV filtration

Whirlpool WHES30 Water Softener
  • 30,000 grain capacity

  • Easy Installation

  • NSF Certified


Best Well Water Softeners

1. Pentair WS48-56sxt 10 Fleck Water Softener – Top Water Softening System for Well Water

  • Product Dimensions: 10 x 10 x 54 inches
  • Weight: 130 Pounds
  • Grain Capacity: 48,000
  • Flow Rate: 14 GPM

More Features: It features meter based regeneration where the system will only regenerate when it requires doing so. It measures your water usage and starts the regeneration process accordingly due to which you save a lot of salt and water in the long run. The paddlewheel style meter works best as compared to the turbine-style in terms of water leakage.

Pentair offers a commercial-grade water softening unit that is considered as one of the best for treating well water. It removes calcium and magnesium from water that causes hardness with the help of the ion exchange process.  

Pentair removes scale deposits and prevents scale build-up in pipelines and other surfaces. It protects your plumbing system and appliances and increases their life. With the elimination of hard water, your skin and hairs also remain soft. Also, you will be able to drink clean and pure water.

If we talk about its reliability, then it is a long-lasting and reliable water treatment system. It comes with standard brine and mineral tanks, bypass valve, and adapter. It is also quite easy to install. All you need is to follow the instructions properly. Also, the installation videos are there in USB to make the installation process easier for you.   

The Fleck 5600sxt control head features an LCD that provides all the information and error codes with great readability. Also, the touchpad controls make it easy to control the overall system. Other than this, the SXT controller also features 48 hours of internal power backup.  

2. On the Go OTG4-DBLSOFT Portable Grain RV Water Softener – Best Portable Water Softener for Well Water

  • Product Dimensions: 22 x 9.5 x 9.5 inches
  • Weight: 32 Pounds
  • Grain Capacity: 16,000

More Features: This RV/marine water softener also offers excellent flow rate. It slightly drops the water pressure, which is definitely acceptable.

If you are looking for a water softener for your RV, then this portable water softener by On the Go is the ideal choice for you. It is the largest RV water softener available in the market that can turn the hardness of well water into softness.

It generates more soft water as compared to many units available. With two salt boxes, it can deliver up to 1600 gallons of soft water or can work for 40 days. Also, it only takes 30 minutes for regeneration.

With this portable water softener, there is no need to carry bottled water along with you while traveling. Its compact and space-saving design makes it easy to install anywhere. Also, it doesn’t need any tool for installation.

The unit offers simple and quick regeneration to make the water soft. It features a large mouth opening to add salt without any problem. Also, it has an easy-to-carry handle so that you can take it anywhere.

If we talk about performance, then it is quite effective in removing hardness from water. Also, it enhances the taste of water and removes unpleasant smell. Moreover, it prevents scale build-up along with avoiding the rust stains.

3. Iron Pro 2 Water Softener Fleck 5600SXT – Best Water Softener with Excellent Grain Capacity

  • Product Dimensions: 14 x 7 x 21 inches
  • Weight: 119.5 Pounds
  • Grain Capacity: 64,000

More Features: This water softener is also quite easy to install. It comes with a brine tank, installing instructions, and the bypass valve.

This whole house water softener by Fleck is a good quality product that only filters calcium and magnesium ions but also removes iron. Moreover, it makes the water free from rust, sediment, and sand.

It offers a good flow rate so that your complete house gets the same and good water flow. Fine mesh resin is designed to increase the filter life and for the removal of high levels of iron. With 64,000 grain capacity, it is one of the top well water softeners available on the market.

Fleck is also featured with a 5600sxt digital metered valve. This SXT controller is truly built on 5600 valves. This meter based regeneration system is ideal for saving water and salt. It determines your water usage and starts the regeneration process accordingly.

If we go deep into its performance, then this Iron Pro 2 eliminates hardness from water up to 75 GPG. Also, manganese can be removed up to 6 ppm and iron up to 6 to 8 ppm. It eliminates scale build-up and increases the life of your appliances, faucets, plumbing systems, and everything that comes in contact with water. Also, you won’t find the red stains of iron on any surface.

4. Tier 1 Digital Water Softener for Hard Water – Economical Water Softener

  • Product Dimensions: 10 x 10 x 62 inches
  • Weight: 135.6 Pounds
  • Grain Capacity: 48,000

More Features: The system comes with all the required components and parts for easy installation. It includes brine tank, mineral tank (pre-filled), brine tubing, water line connections, and control valve with manual bypass valve.

Hard water damages your plumbing systems, faucets, appliances, skin, hairs, and all other things that come in contact with water. Therefore, you need one of the perfect well water softener that can prevent these damages and increase the life of your appliances. In short, you need Tier 1 digital water softener.

Its digital meter control panel is different from the Fleck 5600sxt in terms of ease of operation. Also, it carries improved features. The turbine meter control valve comes with a manual bypass along with an LCD to show all the required information. This valve head is quite easy to operate with no confusing codes or symbols. Also, it offers adjustable cycle times.

Tier 1 helps you to save your money. It prevents extra soap usage, increases the life of your appliances and plumbing fixtures by preventing and removing scale deposits.

Overall, the product is quite effective and efficient in removing hardness from water. With 48,000 grain capacity, it is an ideal product to buy.

5. ABCwaters Triple Combo Whole House Fleck 5600sxt Water Softener System – Offers Decent Flow Rate

  • Weight: 148 Pounds
  • Grain Capacity: 48,000
  • Flow Rate: 12 GPM

More Features: The upflow carbon tank doesn’t require backwash to provide effective filtration. It means you don’t need to plug in to provide electricity to the system. Also, there is no need for a drain line and no wastage of water.

This unit from ABCwaters is a combination of carbon filtration system, whole house water softening system, and an RO drinking water system. It is a great product that offers you clean, soft, and pure water to use and drink.

First, we are going to talk about the water softener that is a whole house system featured with a 5600SXT controller. This digital valve meter makes the operation easier and comfortable for you. The water softening unit uses cross-linked resin and features 48,000-grain capacity.

If we talk about the RO drinking water system, then it features a 5-stage filtration process. Sediment filter and activated carbon block along with thin-film composite membrane and post inline carbon filters work together to remove various impurities from water and make it clean and pure for drinking. It wastes one-liter water to produce a liter of drinking water.

The upflow carbon filtration system removes various harmful contaminants from water along with the RO system. Both of them work together to remove chlorine, chromium, arsenic, heavy metals, fluoride, lead, bacteria, and viruses. Also, the carbon tank filter system eliminates various chemicals and improves the water taste and smell.

6. iSpring WGB32BM 3-Stage Whole House Water Filtration System – Offers Best Extended Protection

  • Product Dimensions: 21 x 8 x 28 inches
  • Weight: 3.06 Pounds
  • Filtration Capacity: 100,000 gallons of water
  • Flow Rate: 15 GPM

More Features: The last filtration stage filters iron and manganese to provide you water free from all the contaminants. This reduction of iron and manganese increase the life of your appliances and protect them from their harsh effects.

The iSpring offers a 3-stage whole house water filtration system that also makes the water soft to provide you clean and soft water from drinking. It removes iron and manganese to save your showering units, faucets, and other appliances from being damaged.

The unit requires minimum maintenance. Also, 1-inch inlet and outlet create only a slight impact on the flow of water. It offers a flow rate of 15 GPM, which is quite decent.

The first stage of water filtration features a sediment filter that is responsible for removing large particles. The second filtration stage uses coconut shell carbon to filter most of the harmful contaminants from the tap water. It eliminates chlorine, industrial solvents, VOCs, pesticides, herbicides, and other pollutants. 

Both the sediment and carbon block filters have a great filtration capacity of 100,000 gallons of water. Also, they both meet the NSF/ANSI standards requirements.  

7. Fleck 48K 5600sxt Iron Pro Eradicator – Best for Iron Removal

  • Product Dimensions: 18 x 30 x 62 inches
  • Weight: 95 Pounds
  • Grain Capacity: 48,000

More Features: It eliminates water hardness up to 50 GPG and removes iron and hydrogen sulfide up to 4 ppm and 2 ppm respectively.  

This water softening unit from Fleck is designed as a whole house water softening unit, but it also responsible for removing iron from water. The fine mesh resin having 48,000-grain capacity work with the KDF 85 Mediaguard to remove hard minerals from water along with eliminating iron. Also, it eliminates the bad smell of hydrogen sulfide that smells like the rotten egg.

It comes with a control head, brine tank, resin, tank, and CanPro Mediaguard. All you need is to install the product by following the provided instructions.

The flow meter measures your water usage, and then the system is regenerated on the basis of that usage. The paddlewheel meter prevents leakage and helps to save salt and water. Also, the LCD display at the control head shows related information and error codes for easy operation. Moreover, touchpad controls make the system controlling easier and quicker.

8. Water Pro 20 with Fleck 5600sxt Water Softener – Average Water Softener

  • Product Dimensions: 12 x 48 x 12 inches
  • Weight: 100 Pounds
  • Grain Capacity: 48,000
  • Flow Rate: 12 GPM

More Features:  The unit also prevents scale build-up and keeps your appliances and plumbing fixtures safe and increases their life.   

This Water Pro 20 water softener from AFWFilters comes with a Fleck 5600sxt digital meter valve that makes system controlling easier and safer. It not only makes the water soft but also eliminates iron and sulfur and improves the water taste and odor.

The digital metered control head with a flow meter measures the quantity of water usage and starts the regeneration process when there is a need. The fine mesh resin can eliminate up to 48,000 grains of hardness before the need for regeneration.

The fine mesh resin removes iron up to 8 ppm, and the catalytic carbon synthetic carbon removes hydrogen sulfide, chemicals, and unpleasant taste and odor from water.

9. Aquasana 500,000 Gallon Well Water Whole House Filter with Salt-Free Descaler – Comes with Filtration System + Descaler + UV

  • Product Dimensions: 69 x 10.5 x 57 inches
  • Weight: 25 Pounds
  • Filtration Capacity: 500,000 gallons of water
  • Flow Rate: 7 GPM

More Features: The unit also comes with a complete installation kit that includes bypass valve, brass fittings, and bend support. But it doesn’t include PEX tubing.

This Aquasana well water treatment unit is a whole house water filter that comes with a salt-free descaler and UV filtration system. It can remove chlorine up to 97% and features a filtration capacity of 500,000 gallons of water. Moreover, the unit also filters sediment, rust, silt, industrial solvents, metals, pesticides, and herbicides.

The salt-free descaler is responsible for reducing and preventing scale build-up. It protects your pipelines, fixtures, appliances, and other things that come in contact with water. It neither adds salt nor requires electricity to make water soft. Other than this, it also offers strong UV filtration that kills almost 100% of viruses, bacteria, and chlorine resistant cysts.

Now, if we talk about the downside of this product, then it has pathetic customer service. Also, according to some users, its filtration and water softening abilities are not up to the mark.

10. Whirlpool WHES30 Water Softener – Least Grain Capacity

  • Product Dimensions: 19 x 18 x 43.5 inches
  • Weight: 102 Pounds
  • Grain Capacity: 30,000

More Features: The unit comes with an installation kit and a bypass valve to install and start the operation in minutes.

The last but not the least water softener on the list is the Whirlpool WHES30. It saves water as well as salt since it only uses them when there is a requirement for regeneration. It measures your usage and regenerates accordingly.

The product is NSF certified for the reduction of hard water symptoms. It eliminates iron from water up to 8 ppm and protects your plumbing systems, fixtures, appliances, and dishes from the effects of hard water.

It provides effective water softening results, no matter whether you are using a well water or city water.

The drawback of this product is that it doesn’t last for long. Also, after some time, the O rings start to leak.

Buyer’s Guide

Water Pro 20 water filter system

In this buyer’s guide section, you are going to learn about the importance of using a water softener for well water, how it works, and what are its main components. And after that, you will know about various factors that you should consider before your purchase.   

Why is it Important to Use Water Softener for Well Water?

Well, water is much harder when we compare it with the city water. Those areas where well water is commonly used, water softeners are also used to treat water hardness.

The presence of calcium, magnesium, and other constituents in well water make it unsafe, polluted, and risky to use. The harsh minerals of well water cause scale build-up in pipelines. This hard water also damages the appliances and dishes. It decreases the lifespan of appliances and other things that come in contact with water.

But the well water hardness not only affects your home appliances, pipelines, and plumbing fixtures but also ruins the softness of your hairs and skin. Moreover, hard-drinking water also causes various health issues, including cardiovascular diseases, reproductive failure, and other problems. Also, the presence of calcium, magnesium, and other harmful elements affect the air quality when you take a shower in the bathroom. And that bad air quality causes different respiratory problems to adults and children.

Therefore, with all these problems and issues associated with the well water hardness, it is necessary to purchase a reliable well water softener to save your money, time, and health.  

What are the Components of Well Water Softener?

There are three different components of the well water softener. One is the mineral tank, the second one is the brine tank, and the third main component is the control valve.

Mineral / Resin Tank is where the hard water becomes soft. It contains plastic beads or resin beads made up of polystyrene. How this resin tank works to make the water soft is discussed below in how does water softener work?

Brine Tank contains a brine solution made with salt or sodium. This brine solution turns the hard minerals into soft. You can also use potassium instead of sodium to make the water soft. But potassium is expensive as compared to sodium. Therefore, it is better to use sodium. But if you are only allowed to consume little amount of sodium, then it is better to use potassium. Some amount of sodium may be transmitted into your body when you drink the soft water. So, if sodium is not good for your health, then use potassium that is environmental friendly as well as won’t affect your health.  

Control Valve

The control valve is the main component of the water softener that tells you the time to clean up the coated resin beads. But there are many water softeners that come with Fleck 5600SXT control head that start the regeneration process when it is required. It finds out your water usage and on the basis of it restarts the regeneration process. It is a smart controller that allows you to control the whole unit with ease.

Presence of Iron in Well Water

Well water not only contains calcium and magnesium, but the presence of iron is another problem associated with the well water. Iron is the most common and real problem for the well water users. It leaves stains on dishes, appliances, faucets, bathroom tiles, and even on anything it contacts with. Therefore, many people look for the iron removing feature of the water softener before purchasing one for the well water.

Most of the water softeners remove or reduce iron effectively along with eliminating minerals that cause hardness. But it is ideal to go for a water softener that uses an iron filter for the removal of iron. It is necessary for the life of the water softener to get water free from iron. Those water softeners that use an iron filter before the water softening system works long as compared to those where the hardness and iron get removed only by the softener resin.

Therefore, if you want to extend the life of your water softener resin and want to prevent the resin matrix from being clogged and coated, then it is necessary to go with an iron filter.

How Do Well Water Softeners Work?

Water softeners contain two separate chambers, a brine tank, and a resin tank. It is a resin tank where the water softening process takes place. Water softeners make use of the process called ion exchange to remove the hardness ions from water. These hardness ions are primarily calcium and magnesium, but iron, manganese, and radium are also included.

The resin tank contains a bed of small beads that have sodium ions electrostatically attached with them. The water softener pumps hard water through this bed of resin beads, and the hardness ions are exchanged with the sodium ions. Now, eventually, the resin will fill up with the hardness ions, and it can’t soften any more water. At that point, the water softener must be regenerated.

Now the water softener goes offline, and brine tank becomes active where the salt brine is pumped into the resin and washes away the hardness ions and replaces them with the fresh layer of sodium ions so that the softener can go back online and resumes softening more water.

Factors to Consider when Purchasing the Best Water Softener for Well Water

There are various things that you should look at before deciding to buy a particular product. So what are those things, take a look.

Type of Unit

First of all, it is necessary to make sure whether you want to purchase a whole house water softening unit or a water filtration system that also softens water. Those areas where well water is used, people prefer to install whole house water filters that also remove calcium and magnesium ions to make the water soft along with removing various impurities. Also, iron is a common well water problem and to deal with this, makes sure that your filtration or water softening unit uses an iron filter.    

Grain Capacity

Grain capacity is the next thing that you should look at. If you are not aware of the term grain capacity, then it refers to the hardness amount that can be eliminated by a water softening unit before the need for regeneration.

Some water softeners feature a grain capacity of only 16,000 like On the Go RV Water Softener whereas some have a gran capacity of 30,000 like Whirlpool WHES30 Water Softener. But it is best to go for those water softeners having grain capacity of 48,000 or 64,000.

Water Flow Rate

Flow rate is also necessary to consider. It is measured in Gallons per Minute (GPM). So, it is needed to go for a unit that offers a good flow rate. More than 10 GPM is good enough to get soft water through every facet of your home.

Filtration Capacity

If you are looking for a whole house water filtration unit, then it is necessary to check its filtration capacity. How much gallons of filtered water it can produce without needing a replacement is essential to check.   

Leave a Comment